By AnchorNews | 19 Nov, 2026 11:12:41am | 105

By Dr. Buchi Nnaji
The Enugu State House of Assembly may have applauded itself for passing the amendment to the Landlord and Tenant Law on Tuesday, November 17th 2026, but residents should not mistake legislative activities for meaningful governance. At a time when decent accommodation is becoming increasingly out of reach, the real question is not whether the legislature can impose some restriction on landlords, but whether it will actually make accommodation accessible to the average man. My view is absolutely clear. The tenancy bill as reported does nothing to address the root causes of the housing crisis in Enugu State. It attempts to regulate the symptoms of a problem whose root causes remain unaddressed. The bill has passed its third reading and is now awaiting Governor Peter Mbah's assent. It is not yet an enforceable law. Reports indicate a 4-year restriction on rent increases, a subsequent 2% cap, and a provision for a 10% rent increase following extensive renovation. THISDAY has reported a provision for a 10% annual rent bond to be paid into an account managed by the Office of the Attorney General. These are the reported provisions; they are not in any way a substitute for the clause-by-clause examination of the actual authenticated bill.
There is no doubt about the severity of the housing problem. In Enugu, it is reported that two-bedroom flats which used to be let for between N400k and N450k per annum in various parts of the city are now being let for between N700k and N800k. In Nsukka, the same accommodation which used to be let for between N350k and N370k is now being let for between N500k and N550k. These are market observations rather than the results of a full rental survey, but they do illustrate the pressure that households are under. What is even more troubling is the movement of the lower-income groups, civil servants, artisans and young families towards the peripheral communities in search of cheaper accommodation, at times to the detriment of access to basic infrastructure. This is not simply a landlord/tenant issue. It is a question of urban development, of household welfare and of the ability of the worker to live within a reasonable distance of his place of work and of his access to basic services.
The same issue is apparent in the academic literature on Enugu's housing situation. A 2023 SAGE Open study examining formal and informal settlements in the Enugu metropolis identified 24 informal settlements. It estimated that they housed over 361,000 people (34.69% of the urban population in the study's analysis). The study found vast differences in housing quality, infrastructure, amenities, and access to services between formal and informal settlements. The upshot is that a large part of Enugu's housing problem is about the availability of decent housing and the conditions in which people are forced to live. A tenancy bill that only limits rent increases and says nothing about providing decent housing will address only a negligible fraction of the problem.
The 2% ceiling is probably the most economically dubious aspect of the proposed amendment. If a landlord is only allowed to increase rent once every four years and that increase is capped at 2% of the existing rent, the total permitted increase over the four years works out to an effective nominal increase of around 0.5% per annum (before inflation). Take an example of a rent of ₦500,000. 2% of that is ₦10,000, which is the total after four years. That's the total permitted increase under the general rule as reported, not an annual increase. What economic evidence was there to lead the legislators to believe that such a ceiling would be viable across all types of property, all locations, and all levels of maintenance? What happens when the cost of repairing a roof, replacing plumbing, servicing the electrics, maintaining security, or restoring a building in a state of decay increases dramatically over those four years? A flat ceiling that doesn't take account of such realities is not economic regulation at all. It is arbitrary price control. It also doesn't distinguish between a landlord simply making excessive profits and a property owner trying to maintain the value and habitability of a legitimate investment.
The economic contradiction is even more apparent when you look at the policy in the context of the rental market's structure. Inflation doesn't wait four years to bite into the cost of building materials, labor, transport, electricity, security, and maintenance. Nor do borrowing costs, land values, and the cost of the various inputs into construction just get frozen in place because some state legislature has decided to put a rent ceiling in place. Equally, the economic situation of a property in Independence Layout can't be equated with that of a very modest building in a developing area, and just as a newly built apartment can't be treated as economically equivalent to an older building in need of massive repairs. A rigid 2% ceiling across such disparate situations would be likely to have the effect of discouraging investment in rental property, of encouraging landlords to defer maintenance, of reducing the incentive to build new rental property and of pushing some of the transactions into the informal sector. Those are all very real risks that legislators should have properly considered rather than ignored. The aim should be to prevent arbitrary and exploitative increases without destroying the incentives for responsible investment. Tenant protection and property rights are not incompatible; the right legislation will strike a balance between the two.
The 10% allowance for 'substantial renovation' is another potential minefield. What constitutes 'substantial renovation'? Does a roof replacement, rewiring, bathroom renovation, or a new water system count? How will the allowable increase be calculated? Against the actual outlay? Against the property value? Against the market rental rate? Who will be the independent assessor of the work, and what stops a tenant from simply doing routine maintenance and calling it 'substantial renovation'? Unless those questions are properly answered, it could be a very easy route to abuse and a new source of dispute. The 10% tenancy deposit is also subject to question. If tenants are required to put a 10% tenancy deposit of the annual rent into a government-managed account, the government must explain why that is necessary, how the funds will be protected, the conditions for release, and the time within which release will be made. At a time when prospective tenants are already facing the full brunt of rent, agency fees, and other accommodation costs, the government must be absolutely certain the proposed protection doesn't add another financial burden.
The House of Assembly must also show that the legislation is underpinned by sufficient evidence. The chair of the committee reportedly said the bill resulted from extensive stakeholder consultation, and that there was a public hearing on March 26th 2026. That's all very well, but consultation doesn't, in itself, mean the policy is sound from an economic point of view. Where is the published impact assessment? Where is the rental market data to support a uniform 2% cap? What modeling has been done to assess the likely impact on housing supply, property maintenance, private investment, and the availability of rental accommodation? What evidence supports the chair of the committee's reported assertion that the amendment would, in effect, subsidize over 60% of what people previously paid to get accommodation? A rent cap is not, strictly speaking, a subsidy. If the 60% figure refers to savings on agency, legal, and other accommodation costs, then the committee should be able to identify the costs in question, the calculation method, and the evidence for the figure. People are entitled to proper, verifiable explanations, not just some impressive-sounding percentage.
Governor Peter Mbah must not regard the passage of the bill as a mere formality in enacting legislation. He should not simply go along with it. Before he signs it, he should require a full legal and economic analysis of the bill's provisions as they would apply to existing and new tenancies, newly built properties and properties of different classes, substantial renovations, tenancy bonds, agency charges, and the dispute resolution process. The Government must also issue clear implementation guidelines, establish an accountable enforcement mechanism, and provide a transparent process for complaints and appeals. The reported amendment to the Landlord and Tenant Law (Cap. 101) Revised Laws of Enugu State 2024 should be treated as a complete package of legislation, not simply a legislative triumph based on a few headline provisions. The 2% ceiling in particular must be subject to economic analysis. If it can't stand up to that analysis, it should be looked at. If it is ambiguous in any way, it must be clarified. If the bond regime will in fact result in unnecessary hardship, it must be reviewed. That is the Governor's responsibility. It is not to just go along with the legislature's enthusiasm.
More fundamentally, Enugu needs a housing policy that focuses on increasing supply rather than one that essentially restricts what existing property owners can do. Government has to take responsibility for delivering large-scale affordable housing, facilitating public-private partnerships, facilitating access to housing finance, providing serviced land, improving infrastructure, and providing the right kind of incentives to developers so that they will, in fact, build decent, genuinely affordable rental accommodation. The pressure on the Enugu metropolis, the housing needs of the Nsukka student population, and the growth of new urban centers all require a coordinated response to the different housing needs of the various groups of people in the city, i.e., the worker, the student, the young family, and the low-income household. It is completely indefensible for the government to spend all its legislative effort restricting what private landlords can charge without at the same time showing an equally determined commitment to increasing the stock of affordable houses for the people. It also needs to address the continuing proliferation of poorly serviced informal settlements through proper urban planning and investment in infrastructure.
Ultimately, the new tenancy bill lays bare a fundamental failing of the state's approach to public policy, treating the symptoms rather than the root causes. Enugu's housing crisis results from a combination of factors including insufficient supply, rising construction costs, declining purchasing power, poor access to housing finance, inadequate infrastructure, and the total absence of a sufficiently ambitious public housing response. Rent regulation may be one element of a broader housing strategy, but it will not in any way replace that strategy. The Enugu State House of Assembly must realize that passing a tenancy bill is not the same as resolving a housing crisis. The Governor must also realize that residents cannot live in legislative promises. Enugu needs more houses, not just restrictions on landlords; it needs genuine affordability, not political platitudes; and it needs a housing policy based on evidence, investment, and economic reality. A government cannot regulate its way out of a housing deficit that it has failed to address.
Dr. Buchi Nnaji is a public and political affairs analyst. He writes from Enugu State, Nigeria.
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *
Interviews
Politics
Crime & Security
Technology
Education
News
Business & Economy
Religion
Entertainment
Health
Sports
Culture & Tourism